Friday, April 9, 2010

Post your comments on the following questions by Tuesday, the 13th.

Reading for April 12th: "The Lottery" (587), by Shirley Jackson.

"A Hunger Artist", by Frank Kafka.

Also, read "Everyday Use" (1306)along with the above two short stories for our class discussion on Wednesday, the 14th.


1. What are your thoughts on the short story "The Lottery"?

2. Discuss any ideas that came to you when reading "A Hunger Artist".

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Example of analysis and explication - Dr. Pruss

Many readers believe that description is the least important part of any story and can be skipped without much consequence; however, the description at the opening of Jean Toomer’s “Blood-Burning Moon” not only is significant because it conveys the story’s setting but is also important because it foreshadows events sets the tone of the entire story. Skipping the description causes the reader to miss the setting of the story, to fail to gather hints of the inhumane events about to happen, and to neglect to perceive the ominous feelings the story conveys. Missing these important clues makes for a historically inaccurate and an emotionally absent reader who, most likely, will not fully understand or enjoy the story.


Most notable, in the very first sentence of the story “Blood-Burning Moon,” the narrator repeats the word “up,” three times and a fourth time at the beginning of the second one. The walls, the floor, the moon – all are rising, but the hour is “dusk,” a time when dark and light are mixed and things should be dying down and setting. Normally, rising is considered to be a positive movement; however, this bloody moon “Glowing like a fired pine-knot” and the movement of Louisa’s mind “vaguely upon [Bob and Tom] as she walks over the crest of the hill coming from white folks’ kitchen” (1274) while the “The moon was rising” (1275) increasingly are not positive omens. Everything portends something that is about to happen, and although no one knows exactly what it is, the sensations are threatening. After all, images of destruction abound from the start. The walls are “skeleton stone walls” reminiscent of bones without flesh or a corpse; the walls are almost human since they are described as “skeleton,” and the new economy that the emancipated slaves are taking part in which is reflected in the description of the "rotting" floor boards lets the reader know that it is not allowing the African American people to lead better lives; finally, the factory is described as a “pre-war cotton factory,” informing the reader that the freed men are currently working in the same building they worked in while they were slaves. The ghosts of the pasts haunt the black people in their new lives. Furthermore, “pre-war cotton” immediately brings pictures of slaves working the fields to mind. The reader can picture the slaves bending in the heat and picking the crops. Then the reader sees “shanties aligned along the single street of factory town” – a ghettoized slum. Clearly the moon’s “pine-knot” glow ”illumined the [factory’s] great door,” and the black begin to sing “against its spell.” Nothing promising is about to happen here. Fear, doom, death, and blood mark the beginning of Jean Toomer’s story. Though the story is taking place during the early years of reconstruction, the remnants of slavery still abound within the culture. The landscape and nature carry the bloodshed and the spirit of all the evil that has transpired here over the years and all that is yet to come in this story.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Respond by Tuesday, April 6th.

1. Do you think that Louisa is in any way a victim? Discuss whether you believe that either of the men love Louisa with textual evidence to prove it?

2. Feel free to put forth any ideas that struck you when reading this story. You could also post questions about any aspect related to the subject matter and I hope everyone responds and gets a discussion going.

For next week: We will do a mini workshop with Paper 2. No, you will not be exchanging papers with your peers. We will discuss a little bit about Works Cited so that there are no errors on your final draft of Paper 2. Please bring in your papers on Wednesday next week for the workshop.
The deadline for submission of Paper 2 -(hard copy only) after all revisions is Friday, April 19th. No late submissions will be accepted.

We will also discuss "Blood Burning Moon", "Everyday Use" and "Lynching in Tennessee".

Quiz on Friday, the 9th, on the above three stories. Do not miss it.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Drafts of Paper 2 due

Hope you all had a pleasant, enjoyable Spring break!

Just a reminder that your drafts for Paper 2 are due tomorrow, Wednesday, the 03/31/10.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Paper 2 Thesis Topics

Paper Assignment #2
English 106W Mega section
Dr. Pruss
Characterization & Theme
Due Date: Wednesday, March 31st

Please select one topic from the ones listed below. Turn in all your rough work, and put your final draft on top; make sure your final draft is stapled on the top left side. Your paper must include citations (at least 2) from the LiterActive document library and the short stories you use, and you must provide a Works Cited List using the MLA documentation style provided on your LiterActive Disk. You may also use any of the YouTube videos I’ve shown during class or any of the articles on the syllabus instead of one of the LiterActive documents as a source. Failure to cite your sources correctly, and place commas and periods where they belong, will cost you points on your paper grade (since it just takes patience and time; not taking that time shows that you do not care about your work). Please remember to explain the word choice in the quotations you use and demonstrate the connections you see between the passages you choose and the idea you are proving. Write simply and straightforwardly.

1. Using one of the following stories to prove that the character who appears most normal and follows mainstream cultural constructs is the one in greatest need of human compassion and transformation. Make sure you provide sufficient evidence for your viewpoint and that you explain your evidence clearly. This essay topic asks you to construct a convincing and persuasive argument that proves something. You may choose to write this on either “Sonny’s Blues” or “Everyday Use.”
2. What do you believe Jean Toomer is trying to teach you through her story “Blood-Burning Moon”? What do you make of Tom Burwell and his choice of action? What do you make of Louisa? Is she really oblivious to what is happening at the end of the story?
3. Discuss the use of music in Baldwin and Toomer. How are jazz and vocal music used in these stories. Please note the different time periods in which these stories were written. The contexts are different, so make sure you differentiate the historical background’s impact upon the use of music in the story.
4. Discuss the similarities between Mrs. Dutta and Sonny’s brother. Why are these similarities significant thematically?
5. What is Walker’s commentary on the value of education in the story “Everyday Use”? What is your evidence. Why would she want to convey that message?
6. Discuss the first sentence of “Mrs. Dutta Writes a Letter” and the amount of information it carries. Show how this one sentence foreshadows so much. Think carefully about the simile. Discuss the importance of the title, particularly the verb. What is so amazing about the result of the writing that it appears in the title? What does this teach you about writing-to-learn as opposed to having your thesis statement before you begin to write?

Thursday, March 18, 2010

For this week.

1. Discuss the significance of the letter in "Mrs. Dutta Writes a Letter"?

Dr. Pruss's question regarding Alice Walker's "Everyday Use":

2. How does Dee's mother's dream of the television show reveal Dee's character? How
about the way Dee read to her family while she was growing up? What does that tell us about Dee?

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Some thoughts on "Mrs Dutta Writes a Letter"

Here are some of my thoughts as well as my colleagues’ on the story to help you in interpreting the story.

Some info on Mrs. Dutta's cultural background:

Mrs. Dutta belongs to the traditional school of thought which believes that the wife/mother/daughter –in-law is the one who keeps the family in order. She is the one who ensures harmony in a household. Mrs. Dutta belongs to the joint family system, mostly prevalent in northern India, where the new bride lives with her husband, his parents and his siblings along with their spouses. Even though I come from a nuclear family set up, I personally know families that are very traditional in set up, with a highly educated attitude and respectful of each other’s space, unlike Mrs. Dutta’s situation where she had not known what privacy meant. But there are of course families with many problems in this type of set up. The probability of conflict is high when there are so many individuals under one roof whose opinions clash constantly and "individuality" suffers in pursuit of the collective good. Only, Mrs. Dutta never really realized her individuality since her environment has fostered the belief that the purpose of her existence is solely based on the needs of not only her immediate family members, but her extended family as well.

The part where Mrs. Dutta says that it was a relatively good day in a country where you could stare out for hours and not see a soul was hilarious for me because it is exactly what my aunt and mother say though in a lighthearted manner, when they visit me here occasionally. For instance, the city and especially the residential area where my parents live in India is peaceful as well, but the social scene is drastically different. There’s always someone who drops by, be it the housemaid who comes everyday at 6:30 a.m., the familiar vendor who brings fresh greens every day, or the milkman, or the dry cleaning boy who picks up and drops off clothes, or the errand boy from the provision store who drives by with groceries ordered by my mother over the phone. There is a constant hum of sounds which I find soothing whether it is the cook chopping veggies or the maid mopping the floors. The point with all these details is that it is a totally different lifestyle in India (especially for the slightly privileged). It is a huge change for any Indian immigrant no matter how educated or modern he or she is when they move to America. My folks belong to a traditional educated Indian society and they appreciate a whole lot of things about America and its culture but they cannot imagine living here. For Mrs. Dutta, it is about realizing that she belongs with her own circle of friends in India and not with her family. I think some aspects of American culture which she sees through her daughter in law helps her in this realization. Her selflessness is no good to her or to her own family.

In short, Mrs. Dutta is enslaved to an archaic mode of thinking – that the woman takes the responsibility of ensuring harmony in a household by suppressing her own voice for the supposed good of the family. Her reluctance to understand her daughter-in-law is annoying which shows how out of touch she is with her true “self”. On the other hand, I find it unacceptable that Mrs. Dutta’s son, his wife and kids have alienated themselves from their own rich heritage, manners and respect of elders(which I didn't elaborate upon since it will be too lengthy) instead of finding a balance between the two worlds.It is a relief to find that Mrs. Dutta becomes her own champion in the end. The letter she writes is her courage to finally face the truth.
-Sunita


Ms. Botelho said:
This story is not all that different than many stories written by a foreigner trying to establish a place in America. The repulsion at American children, television, and the "loose" woman smoking a cigarette is expected in a story like this. However, it was the last paragraph that brought this story to an unexpected (and pleasantly surprising) level. We see the narrator, Mrs. Dutta, actually learning something about people through her experience in America, as opposed to shunning the culture she finds herself in. In the letter to her close friend in Calcutta, because there is no repercussion to writing the truth, she is finally able to do so. There are a few moments in the story Mrs. Dutta reflects on the unbridled emotion Americans showcase, and how this never occurred in her homeland. After these judgments, she is struck by a view that perhaps this isn't a bad thing, as she reflected on the feelings of repression she experienced in her own life. She does not shed tears as she writes and admits these truths, because she was actually shedding tears when she denied them to herself.

Daniel M said:
My first impression of the story is that it prominently concerns the production of texts and the circumstances or contexts that inform writing. It builds on the many tensions Mrs. Dutta faces in America: conflicts between Mrs. Dutta and a combination of her son’s family and American culture. Yet, through many of these conflicts, she is silent—owing to the selflessness that defines the “mother” role in her culture. I apologize for not being able to accurately point to the source of the quote, but someone said in the afternoon class last Monday that “without a voice there isn’t a self,” or something similar. Mrs. Dutta represses every outwardly selfish thought, barring those that concern a more traditional way to go about doing things for her family. Thus, the final production of the letter is a triumph for Mrs. Dutta’s selfhood. She informs her friend that she will be returning to India and seeking happiness on her own terms rather than those of culturally-mandated obligation and tradition. Not sending the letter would negate the purpose of the story, so I’m certain that the letter gets mailed and that Mrs. Dutta eventually returns to her native land.

Mr. Bolster said:
Mrs. Dutta was crying because of the truths within herself that she repressed.
Whatever is in her heart that she cannot name exists in opposition to her family loyalties. Divakaruni uses the word "battles" to illustrate this quality of opposition and conflict. First of all, whatever it is that Mrs. Dutta feels, she identifies as incommensurable with family loyalty--an important value for her throughout the story and a value that she identifies with her homeland and its traditions.

Her insidious feelings may include the feeling that Sagar and his wife have made horrible mistakes in the way they choose to live their lives. The rebelliousness of the children and the idea of a woman smoking a cigarette are aspects of the "modern American world" with which Mrs. Dutta takes issue, but it is also the strange washing machine, the strange way that neighbors don't talk to one another, and the strange way a wife addresses a husband by his first name. Mrs. Dutta experiences a generalized feeling of cultural and social alientation in the "new world." The cultural alienation Mrs. Dutta could have expected, coming to America, but the sense of alienation from her family, her own flesh and blood, probably took her by surprise. "And blood is blood after all" (363), Mrs. Dutta says to Mrs. Basu, explaining why she can't possibly dislike moving to America. Disappointment is another feeling that she cannot immediately put into words, although she eventually acknowledges that feeling to herself. She is disappointed with "so much in this country" (359), which is a generalized disappointment, but she is specifically disappointed with her grandchildren. How difficult for any grandparent to admit that! Eventually, her disappointment and alienation build into, presumably, regret that she moved, or at the very least, a resolution to return to India.

On another note altogether, I love how Divakaruni completely underemphasized Mrs. Dutta's decision to return to her homeland. In fact, I didn't even notice it the first time I read the story. It's in the middle of the letter on the last page: "for I do hope you will rent [your downstairs flat] to me on my return" (369).

Mr. Farell said:
The feelings she refuses to name are: loneliness, sadness, and depression. Although she loves her family and is loyal to them, her problem is filling the days and having a true sense of companionship. "It's been a good day, as good as it can be in a country where you might stare out the window for hours and not see one living soul" (363). She feels loss for the friendship of her dearest, closest companion, Roma, who is also who she is writing the letter to. "Calcutta pushes itself on her mind again...and her heart fills with a sense of loss she knows to be illogical" (364). She is heartbroken from the home and culture she has known all of her life. She constantly drifts into moments of nostalgia that she deems "illogical" for a reason. This is what she discovers in her letter at the end that her happiness is where she left her heart--India. This is why she feels no need to weep because she has made the decision that will make her happiest. She feels that she is losing nothing by going home.


Skylar Hammel said:
The feelings that Mrs. Dutta cannot name are her knowledge of her own unhappiness and the lack of acceptance in her new life. It is obvious that Mrs. Dutta is trying to adapt to the situation she is in, but cannot succeed. When she cannot sleep in, she does not get out of bed early in order to keep from waking the family. However, she suffers for her attempt by being forced to remain on a mattress she finds uncomfortable until other people in the household begin their day. They begin their day exactly when they want to; she is not given that luxury. As a young bride she had kept the hours needed to run the house. As an live-in, aged parent she keeps the hours necesary for the smooth operation of the house according to American standards. In both places, she was denied the right to keep her own schedule as she pleased.
The word insidious appears more than once in the text. As Mrs. Dutta muses on Shyamoli's way of life and her refusal to bend to other people's rules, she uses the same adjective. "Mrs. Dutta lowers herself heavily on to her bed, trying to erase such an insidious idea from her mind" (366). The insidious idea is, at least in part, longing for the freedom lost by attempting to fit the mold of the aging Indian mother.